Stan Taylor
The WireOct 5, 2026Politics

The New Republic judges GOP trans ads without counting them

A coach in a white blazer and a “Trans Kids Belong” T-shirt shouts with both arms spread wide on a basketball sideline.
Photo via The New Republic

The New Republic

Pathetic Republicans “Trans”-ition to Their Vile Closing Argument
Read it where it was published

Two adjectives arrive before a single number, so you feel contempt first and never miss the count. The verdict becomes something to repost; the $60 million and the names of who paid stay off the page.

On October 5, The New Republic ran an opinion column by editor Michael Tomasky calling the GOP’s trans-themed midterm ads a “vile closing argument.” CNN, citing AdImpact, counts more than 190 such ads and $60 million.

What they said

From the start of 2026 to late September, GOP advertisers spent more than $60 million on more than 190 TV ads referencing transgender policies, according to AdImpact data reported by CNN on September 27.

  1. The New RepublicByron Donalds, Republican nominee for Florida governor, about Democratic opponent David JollyOct 5, 2026

    “David Jolly is somebody who thinks it’s still okay for boys to be in girls’ sports”

    Quoted in the column’s second paragraph, which links to The 19th as its source.

    Read it where it was published
  2. CNNSep 27, 2026

    Facing a barrage of Republican anti-trans ads, some Democrats are changing how they respond

    The story that carries the count: more than 190 ads, more than $60 million.

    Read it where it was published
  3. The Washington SunTerry Schilling, president of the American Principles ProjectSep 29, 2026

    “This is like the one area where the Republicans have a clear contrast to go on offense.”
    Read it where it was published
  4. The Washington SunTerry Schilling, president of the American Principles ProjectSep 29, 2026

    “Here’s where we’re weakest: Voters are still hung up about $5 a gallon gas, about the war in Iran”
    Read it where it was published
  5. Punchbowl NewsRep. Marcy Kaptur (D-Ohio), in a direct-to-camera adSep 22, 2026

    “I voted with Republicans to keep transgender ideology out of our schools.”
    Read it where it was published
  1. “Pathetic” A verdict on a whole party, placed first. It hands you contempt, which feels like knowing, before you learn how many ads ran or who paid for them.

  2. ““Trans”-ition” A pun in scare quotes. A word that names people becomes a wink about strategy, and the reader is invited to share the joke.

  3. “Vile Closing Argument” “Vile” adds disgust. “Closing argument” says final pitch, yet Punchbowl’s count puts most of 82 broadcast ads in GOP primaries, and CNN’s count runs from January.

  4. “boys” One word decides who a trans girl is before any argument is made. The same verdict in a word, from the other side.

  5. “go on offense” The ad-maker’s own frame is a battlefield. In the same interview he names gas and Iran as “where we’re weakest.”

  6. “transgender ideology” A Democrat speaking the Republican phrase. “Ideology” turns people into a doctrine to keep out, and a headline about “Republicans” has no room for her ad.

The analysis

Two adjectives hold the headline up. “Pathetic” and “Vile” are verdicts, and they reach the reader before any ad does. Under them sits an opinion column by editor Michael Tomasky, filed under the kicker “LAST GASP,” with no count of ads, no dollar figure and no sponsor. Its third paragraph opens “It’s pathetic.” The tell is the adjective standing where a number should be: when the judgment comes first and the count never comes, you are handed a feeling to carry, not a fact to weigh.

CNN, citing AdImpact, reports more than 190 GOP TV ads on transgender policies and more than $60 million since January. Punchbowl’s narrower count finds 82 broadcast ads in House and Senate races, most in GOP primaries. Axios names one sponsor: Elon Musk’s America PAC, with ads against Sherrod Brown, Josh Turek, James Talarico and Mary Peltola. PolitiFact found a Kansas ad that stitched separate sentences into a quote Adam Hamilton never said. None of it reaches the headline.

The same eyes for the other side. In Byron Donalds’s line, quoted in the column itself, the word “boys” names trans girls and settles the question before an argument starts. The headline’s villain is “Republicans” alone, while Democrats Marcy Kaptur, Lindsay James and Sarah Trone-Garriott run ads against trans athletes in girls’ sports, Kaptur in the phrase “transgender ideology.” Trans people are the subject of every ad and every headline here, and no headline quotes one.

The money. More than $60 million behind more than 190 GOP TV ads this year, per AdImpact. In CNN’s poll, 25% of voters called trans issues “extremely important,” last of 11 issues tested.

The history. In 2024 the Trump campaign’s best-known trans ad said Kamala Harris was for “they/them” and, in the same spot, promoted Trump’s middle-class tax cut plan.

The calendar

  1. Sep 9, 2026Axios reports Musk’s America PAC trans ads in four Senate races
  2. Sep 27, 2026CNN reports $60 million and 190 ads, per AdImpact
  3. TodayTNR calls the ads a “vile closing argument”
  4. Nov 3, 2026US midterm elections

From the book

Loaded Language: Emotive Framing

“Pathetic” and “Vile” do the work an argument would do. The column under them never counts an ad or names a sponsor, so the verdict is the whole case.

Chapter 23, Linguistic Hacks

Two shops under one owner

The ads sell disgust at Democrats who let “boys” into girls’ sports; the headline sells contempt for “Pathetic Republicans.” Both shops sell indignation at the other team, and trans people are the subject of both while speaking in neither.

Part III: The Shadow Academy

Your move

  • The Master Question: you are being handed contempt, with disgust on the side, 29 days before the midterms. Contempt feels like being right, and it is easy to pass on. Why do they need your anger? Feel it on purpose, or not at all.
  • Does it touch you? If you are trans, raise a trans child, or vote in a race these ads target, decide what your plan is for November 3. If not, it is weather: watch it without bleeding or feeding.
  • Your nudge: which word pulled harder, “Pathetic” or “boys”? Name the one that felt true, and the belief it pressed on. The same two words push two readers in opposite directions; question the side you are on too.

Sources The New RepublicCNN2Punchbowl NewsThe Washington SunAxiosPolitiFact